Talk:Embra
Frae Wikipedia
We already have an article on Edinburgh... /Bryan
- Actually, we have an article on the "City of Edinburgh". This would refer to Edinburgh itself, while the Ceity o Edinburrie article refers to the unitary authority area. --Colin Angus Mackay 16:12, 29 Jui 2005 (UTC)
- I think that is a rather superficial distinction. I think the articles should be merged. There should be a subsection in this article for the authority, but that is just me. /Bryan
- Maybe... I'm mostly translating from the English version which has both. The council area of the City of Edinburgh also includes the towns of South Queensferry, Kirkliston and some villages which I wouldn't consider being part of Edinburgh. I would consider anything outside the City Bypass to be outside Edinburgh (and in the north, just draw a line from the end of the bypass through the Crammond Brig to the Firth of Forth, anything west of that is outside). However, that may just be an opinion of mine. At the moment I'm in two minds. So I'll sleep on it and probably change my mind in the morning :) --Colin Angus Mackay 23:01, 29 Jui 2005 (UTC)
- I agree with Colin's first response and I'm glad his sleep changed nothing here. Quite distinct concepts (although only the one about the unitary authority has precise boundaries). For some cities the distinction is insignificant, but for others it can be great (eg what is Aberdeen, what is London, what is Dunedin?). So as to present eventually a consistent set of local authority area pages and a consistent set of "city" pages, keep them separate. Robin Patterson 23:30, 14 Mairch 2006 (UTC)
- I think that is a rather superficial distinction. I think the articles should be merged. There should be a subsection in this article for the authority, but that is just me. /Bryan